Other Sheep Breeds
The Dorper and Texel have a much larger carcase size and grow faster, but have almost no worm resistance and require constant deworming.
They need weekly FAMACHA testing and drenching, and so are unsuitable for building a large "hands free" flock in Tennessee.
The Katahdin and Royal White sheep breeds have a large carcase and worm resistance, as these breeds are derived from the St. Croix.
The Katahdin is a cross between the St. Croix and Wiltshire Horn and other breeds, while the Royal White is a cross between the St. Croix and a White Dorper.
Both the Katahdin and Royal White breeds have higher worm resistance than the Dorper and Texel and so need less deworming, but they are still not "hands free" as they require testing and drenching.
If any of these four large commercial breeds were suitable for Tennessee, they would have already produced large commercial flocks here.
I am not aware of anyone in Tennessee raising Katahdin or Royal White sheep without occasionally using dewormers.
Here is my experience:
A few years ago, I purchased a registered Royal White ram lamb for breeding purposes, and I never dewormed it. It died from worms before it was a year old.
Although young, this Royal White ram bred one of my St. Croix Ewes, and the offspring of this union died from worms before it was 8 months old.
The Royal White breed and cross bred offspring require constant individual attention to survive the worm load in Tennessee.
In a way, I was fortunate that the Royal White lamb did not pass on its less worm resistant genetics to the rest of my St. Croix flock.
But the perceived advantage is that the Dorper, Texel, Katahdin, and Royal White sheep breeds are much "larger" than the St. Croix and so are considered "better" by commercial sheep buyers.
These larger breeds are highly sought after, but are rare and limited in availability in Tennessee due to the labor cost involved.
Dorper Sheep (180-230 lbs.)
Texel Sheep (185-240 lbs.)
Katahdin Sheep (145-210 lbs.)
Royal White Sheep (150-250 lbs.)